AARP Movies for Grownups Awards
2012
Nominee
Best Movie for Grownups
Alliance of Women Film Journalists
2012
Nominee
Best Writing, Original Screenplay
Tom McCarthy ,
ALMA Awards
2011
Nominee
Favorite Movie Actor
Bobby Cannavale ,
Broadcast Film Critics Association Awards
2012
Nominee
Best Original Screenplay
Tom McCarthy ,
Joe Tiboni ,
Detroit Film Critics Society Awards
2011
Nominee
Best Ensemble
ESPY Awards
2011
Nominee
Best Sports Movie
Film Independent Spirit Awards
2012
Nominee
Best Screenplay
Tom McCarthy ,
GALECA: The Society of LGBTQ Entertainment Critics
2012
Nominee
Unsung Film of the Year
Houston Film Critics Society Awards
2011
Nominee
Best Original Song
The National ,
Best Picture
Best Supporting Actor
Alex Shaffer ,
Best Screenplay
Tom McCarthy ,
Humanitas Prize
2011
Winner
Sundance Film Category
Tom McCarthy ,
Indiana Film Journalists Association, US
2011
Winner
Best Original Screenplay
Tom McCarthy ,
Best Actor
Paul Giamatti ,
2011
Nominee
Best Supporting Actress
Amy Ryan ,
National Board of Review, USA
2011
Winner
Top Ten Independent Films
Online Film Critics Society Awards
2012
Nominee
Best Original Screenplay
Tom McCarthy ,
San Diego Film Critics Society Awards
2011
Nominee
Best Screenplay, Original
Tom McCarthy ,
Southeastern Film Critics Association Awards
2011
Nominee
Best Picture
St. Louis Film Critics Association, US
2011
Nominee
Best Original Screenplay
Tom McCarthy ,
Joe Tiboni ,
Best Artistic/Creative Film (for excellence in art-house cinema)
Torino Film Festival
2011
Nominee
Best Feature Film
Tom McCarthy ,
Utah Film Critics Association Awards
2011
Winner
Best Supporting Actress
Amy Ryan ,
Washington DC Area Film Critics Association Awards
2011
Nominee
Best Film
Best Original Screenplay
Tom McCarthy ,
Writers Guild of America, USA
2012
Nominee
Best Original Screenplay
Tom McCarthy (story/screenplay) ,
Joe Tiboni (story) ,